Medievalists get used to being treated as the permanent bridesmaids,
caught between the grandeur of classical antiquity and the glories of
the Renaissance. Greek medievalists feel this more than most: the
splendours of ancient Greece and the excitements of the formation of
the modem state conspire to leave the medieval period in obscurity.
Even the most committed of Romantic philhellenists found medieval
Byzantium a hard place to love.
It is correspondingly a delightfully bold decision of Columbia
University Press to publish a long and learned edition of a poem
obscure even to Greek medievalists. The work is an anonymous,
fourteenth-century vernacular allegorical poem of just over 1,000 lines
about a political meeting of animals, which ends with a battle between
herbivores and carnivores. The animals make lavish claims, insult each
other, bicker and finally come to blows. So the boar declares: "Even my
hair fulfills a major mission / Within the Western church, deserving
mention: / The padres bless the folk during Asperges / Using a
sprinkler made from hair of mine". The victory of the herbivores - the
prey - over the carnivores is convincingly read by the editors as a
comment on class war, though they are also quick to note that the irony
and sarcasm of the poem deflate all its protagonists. The language, a
weird mixture of the bawdy and the pompous, is readable to a classicist
with a smattering of modern Greek. The translation, the first in
English, is accurate, down to catching the more plodding side of the
rhetoric all too truthfully. The commentary is full, intelligent and
covers linguistic matters particularly well. The introduction is also
helpful and wide ranging. Here is a bizarre and unfamiliar link in the
tradition that runs from Aesop to Animal Farm: a fascinating glimpse
into a neglected literary and political world.
SIMON GOLDHILL (The Times Literary Supplement, February
20, 2004)