Hydroponics
Boak, Robert (rboak@oswego.edu)
Leonard, Thomas (tleonard@oswego.edu)
Oursler, Khristopher (oursler@oswego.edu)
Hydroponics
- the growing of plants without soil.
Nutrients are delivered to the plant in an aqueous solution as opposed to the plant taking them from the soil.
Expands the scope of gardening; makes it possible to grow a wider variety of plants in a wider variety of climates.
General Advantages
A hydroponic acre can yield as many as ten thousand plants whereas an acre of dirt can only raise one third of that. (http://archimedes.galilei.com/raiar/histhydr.html)
Uses 1/30th the amount of water.
Hydroponics allows for the possibility of the growth of crops outside of their indigenous climate.
Crop rotation is unnecessary because there is no depletion of nutrients because there is no soil.
Growing is not regulated by seasonal changes. Hydroponics allows for continual growth throughout the year.
There is little to no risk of weeds or parasites in controlled systems.
Has been successfully used to grow crops outside of our atmosphere.
General Disadvantages
High cost (i.e. initial capital cost, cost to run)
High maintenance (i.e.. constant supervision, pH testing, light adjustments, support)
Requires specialized knowledge and equipment.
It is a more complicated and involved process than dirt farming.
System Types
There are two types of hydroponics systems for delivering the nutrient solution: Passive and Active.
Passive
Passive systems are basic and easier to set up for the novice hydroponics gardener.
Passive systems require materials that retain moisture longer such as vermiculite and sand.
Easily portable, simple and inexpensive.
Ideal for starting seeds, rooting cuttings and experimental purposes.
A disadvantage is lower growth rate.
The common types of passive systems include:
- Wick system
- Drain down system
Wick System
A group of wicks anchored in the medium and stretching down to a nutrient solution reservoir draws moisture upward into the growing medium to reach the roots of the plant.
A disadvantage is that plants do not grow to full maturity because of limited aeration and root zone volume.
Drain Down System
The solution is poured through the system once to three times a day and drained into a container beneath it.
Roots can clog draining channels.
Extremely high maintenance.
Active
Active systems employ pumps and various other devices to pour the solution into the system and uses gravity to drain off the excess in order to be reused.
Active systems require growing mediums that drain rapidly, such as smooth gravel.
There are various types of active hydroponics systems that exist:
- Nutrient Film Technique
- Ebb & Flow
- Top Feed
- Aeroponics
- Sub-Aeration
Nutrient Film Technique (NFT
)
- Nutrient film technique uses little or no medium (which keeps cost down) and works by a continuous flow of nutrient laden solution flowing over the root system.
- This system can produce large-scale crops inexpensively in parts of the world that soil quality is poor.
- Using this system, eight million heads of lettuce could be grown annually on a 2 1/2-acre operation, in comparison with 75,000 produced in the same area by conventional farming techniques. (Resh, 203)
- The greatest problem facing NFT systems has been root dieback caused by inadequate oxygen in the nutrient solution immediately around the roots.
- This problem causes water stress within the plant, which causes wilting and blossom end rot of fruit crops such as tomatoes.
- This system is susceptible to equipment failure and problems arise due to support of the plant.
Ebb & Flow
This is the most popular hydroponics system due to its low maintenance and low cost.
Ebb and Flow systems utilize a growing bed full of medium, that is "flooded to a depth of about one inch for about twenty minutes and then allowed to drain back". (Resh p.214)
These systems are particularly suited for the growing of seedlings, transplants and ornamental potted plants.
There is little risk of equipment failure due to the fact that there is a growing medium that retains some water. Yet, it drains freely to allow oxygen to get to the root system.
Ebb and Flow systems allow for uniform fill and complete drainage during the irrigation cycle, thus leading to uniformity in plant growth.
This type of system can be made fully automatic with the use of computers.
Top Feed
Top feed systems use pumps to carry the water to the top of the growing medium and gravity drains the solution back to the reservoir.
These systems are reliable, require low maintenance and can withstand short-term equipment failure because of the growing medium.
They are suitable for large scale growing of all types of plants.
A disadvantage of this system is that it is expensive to set up. Also, the nutrient solution is only used once.
Top feed systems can use a variety of growing mediums, and are available in a wide range of configurations.
Aeroponics
Aeroponics uses pumps and sprayers to bathe the roots, which are suspended in a supporting container, with a nutrient-oxygen mist as opposed to a solution.
This method is most used in lab studies and not on a large commercial scale. This is due to the expense of setup, possibility of equipment failure and difficulty in plant support.
This system has proven successful in the propagation of hard to root plants.
NASA has experimented with the combination of the Aeroponics system and the Nutrient Film Technique, in order to conserve nutrients for the use of hydroponics in space.
The chief advantage of this type of system, is efficient utilization of greenhouse space by arranging the plants vertically.
A disadvantage of Aeroponics is regulating the consistency of the sprayers to assure constant nutrient flow.
Sub-Aeration
In this system an air pump supplies oxygen to the roots of the plants via air stones.
The solution does not flow to the roots yet they are constantly submerged. The air bubbles supply oxygen to prevent the roots from drowning.
This system works best with plants that have already rooted.
The root systems must be totally artificially supported.
A disadvantage is the lack of overall aeration and root disturbances that restrict plant growth and maturity.
Since the solution must be periodically changed due to depletion of nutrients, the entire system must be disrupted thus shocking the plants and perhaps causing damage.
To deter the growth of algae, it is suggested that the water supply be hidden from light.
The Nutrient Solution
The key to success in hydroponics growing is the management of plant nutrition. This is accomplished by managing the nutrient solution properly.
Contained within this solution are various combinations of nutrients specifically engineered to mimic and/or enhance the nutrient combinations found in soil.
Contained within the nutrient solution are the following chemicals: Nitrogen, Phosphorous, Potassium, Calcium, Magnesium, Sulphur, Iron, Manganese, Zinc, Boron and Copper.
- Nitrogen
- Influential in the production of leaves and the growth of the stem. (Nicholls, 55-56)
- Phosphorus
-Vital in the development of flowers, fruits, leaves and stems. Also encourages growth of healthy roots. (Nicholls, 55-56)
- Potassium
- Used by the cells of a plant during assimilation of energy produced by photosynthesis. (Nicholls, 55-56)
- Calcium
- Spurs root growth. Also facilitates a plant’s absorption of potassium. (Nicholls, 55-56)
- Magnesium
- A component of chlorophyll. Also active in the process of distributing phosphorus throughout the plant. (Nicholls, 55-56)
- Sulphur
- Joins with phosphorus to heighten the effectiveness of that element. Also used in the production of energy. (Nicholls, 55-56)
- Iron
- Important in the production of chlorophyll within a plant. (Nicholls, 55-56)
- Manganese
- Aids a plant in the absorption of nitrogen. (Nicholls, 55-56)
- Zinc
- Necessary component of the energy transference process in a plant. (Nicholls, 55-56)
- Boron
- While it has been established that boron is needed in minute amounts, it is not known precisely how boron is used. (Nicholls, 55-56)
- Copper
- Needed in the production of chlorophyll. (Nicholls, 55-56)
pH Value
The pH value refers to the acidity or alkalinity of the nutrient solution.
pH readings run from 0 to 14 (0-6 acidic; 7 neutral; 8-14 alkaline).
The recommended pH level for a general hydroponic solution is between pH 6 and pH 6.5. (Nicholls, 63)
Many different variables can effect the pH level.
- Temperature
- Amount of light
- Evaporation
- Tap water refining
- Amount of nutrients
With this amount of variables, periodically checking the pH level of the solution is vital to maintain a healthy environment for the growth of the plant
Adjusting the pH level of the nutrient solution can be done simply.
- If a solution is too acidic, add one tablespoon of baking soda to three gallons of solution.
- If a solution is too alkaline, add one tablespoon of white vinegar per four gallons of solution.
Growing Medium
Growing medium is used to lend support to the roots and plant.
A variety of growing medium are utilized for their individual qualities in various types of hydroponic systems.
Some popular examples of growing medium are: sand, brick shards, vermiculite, perlite, gravel, rockwool, sawdust, and polyethylene sheeting.
Advantages: Abundance; Cost is low.
Disadvantages: Poor drainage; Wasteful of nutrients; Salt buildup; Clogs roots easily; Must be sterilized between uses.
Advantage: Shows adaptability of the hydroponic method, good use of used/recycled materials.
Disadvantages: Difficult to work with; Must be scrubbed between uses; May alter pH.
Advantages: Easy to work with; Lightweight (6 to 10 lbs/ ft3{Resh, 394}).
Disadvantages: (Perlite) Retains water, yet is poorly permeated by minerals; (Vermiculite) Can become waterlogged very rapidly.
Advantages: Inexpensive; Easy to keep clean; Cannot become waterlogged.
Disadvantages: Heavy; Dries out quickly.
- Rockwool
(sterile, porous, non-degradable material made from volcanic materials)
Advantages: Lightweight; Easily molded; Uniform application of nutrients to plants; Each plant is fed individually.
Disadvantages: Relatively expensive; Difficult to work with unless moist; Grows algae easily.
Advantages: High water retention; Common; Lightweight; Adaptable to fertilizer.
Disadvantages: Tendency to clot; Compacted by water; Must chemically cleaned; Subject to biological breakdown (mold) because of its organic nature; Cannot use particular woods (walnut. . .) which contain acids that may kill the plants.
Advantages: Used primarily for NFT systems; Inexpensive; Easy to work with.
Disadvantage: Very little root support.
Today’s Hydroponics
- The recent developments in plastics have cut hydroponic system costs which has made hydroponics financially feasible the more people.
- The development of pumps has allowed hydroponic systems to evolve to fully automatic systems.
- Presently, advances are being made in the development of highly specialized hydroponic cultures for use in atomic submarines.
The Future of Hydroponics
Further development of the application of solar heating in hydroponic greenhouses will reduce cost and economic impact of hydroponics.
Currently, plans are being drawn for using the techniques of soil-less culture on space stations, and perhaps one day on surfaces of other celestial bodies (planets, moons, etc.) that don’t have soil.
In the future, developing countries, along with all other nations, will be able to feed many people using less land than current farming techniques.
Advances in lighting technology will lead to a more widespread use of hydroponics in areas with limited seasonal sunlight.
In the future, the application of hydroponics in providing food in areas having vast regions of non-arable land, such as deserts and mountainous terrain, will be more heavily used.
Bibliography
Bridwell, Raymond. Hydroponic Gardening. Santa Barbara: Woodbridge Press, 1989.
Nicholls, Richard E. Beginning Hydroponics. Philadelphia: Running Press. 1990.
Resh, Howard, Ph.D. Hydroponic Food Production. Santa Barbara: Woodbridge Press, 1998.
The History of Hydroponics. http://archimedes.galilei.com/raiar/histhydr.html.