- NCAA All-Americans: 46
- 1982 NCAA Division III Championships: Team - 3rd Place
- Seven NCAA Division III Top Ten Finishes: 1969-9th (College Division); 1980-9th; 1981-10th; 1982-3rd; 1983-6th; 1984-7th; 2002-9th
- Jim Howard: NCAA Division III Coach of the Year (1982), 1988 SUNYAC Coach of the Year, NWCA Division III Hall of Fame, Oswego State Athletic Hall of Fame
- John Walter: Two time NCAA College Division All-American, 1969 National Champion 123 lbs. Oswego State Alumni Athletic Hall of Fame
- Dave Parisi: Three time NCAA Division III All-American, 1982 National Champion 118 lbs. NWCA Division III Hall of Fame, Career Record: 108-29-1, Oswego State Alumni Athletic Hall of Fame
- Doug Morse: Three time NCAA Division III All-American, 1984 National Champion 190 lbs. NWCA Division III Hall of Fame, Career Record: 106-24-1, Oswego State Alumni Athletic Hall of Fame
- Jon Buhner: Three time NCAA All-American 1987, 88, 89; 1988-89 Dr. Sam Molnar SUNYAC Scholar - Athlete Award Recipient, Career Record: 97-28-3, Oswego State Alumni Athletic Hall of Fame
- Tenkoran Agyeman: Three time NCAA Division III All-American 2003, '04, '05; 2004 New York State Collegiate Champion; Career Record: 118-25
- Walter Jaskot: Two time NCAA College Division All-American, Oswego State Alumni Athletic Hall of Fame
- Michael Kohl: Two time NCAA Division III All-American 1995 & 1996, Four Time NYS Collegiate Championship place finisher; Career Record: 104-55, Oswego State Alumni Athletic Hall of Fame
- NCAA Division III Scholar All-Americans: Jon Buhner (1987, 89), Chris Buhner (1989, 1991), Sean O'Sullivan (1992), Shane Facteau (1995), Mike Kohl (1995, 1996), John Ashcraft (1997), Ron Riquier (2000), Vince Daiello (2000), Dane LaPlante (2006), John Spinner (2006), Michael Howard (2009), Eric Leusch (2009), Derrick Smith (2008, 09),
- SUNYAC Team Championships: 6
- 66 Individual SUNYAC Champions
- 15 Individual Empire Collegiate Wrestling Conference Champions
- Mike Howard: Empire Collegiate Wrestling Conference Coach of the Year 1996 & 2001
- SUNYAC Most Outstanding Wrestler: Brian Darling (1989)
- ECWC Most Outstanding Wrestlers: John Hill (1993), Mike DeBellis (1996), Dave Christopher (1998), Carlos Dolmo (1999), Frank Petrucci (2001)
- 2007-08 NCAA Division III Scholar Team
|
