- Ron Davis: Oswego State Career Scoring leader (2128 pts; 1956-60)
- Sean McLaughlin: 2x All-SUNYAC; SUNYAC Player of the Year, SUNYAC All-Tournament Team ('98, '00); Fourth Team All-American; Oswego State 3 pt. FG leader (162), over 1000 career points
- Max Ziel: 36 years (1921-57) as Oswego State Athletic Director; coached baseball, basketball, track, and soccer; 27 years as Men's Basketball Head Coach; founder of SUNYAC Championship Tournament.
- Donald Snygg Award Winners: Mickey Lebowitz (1981), Tom Farney (1993), Tim Szablewski (1996), Bruno Gerard (1997)
- SUNYAC Championship Finalists ('98, '02, '05, '08)
- 2005 ECAC Upstate Tournament Champions
- ECAC Runner-up ('06, '07)
- ECAC Semifinalists (1998, 2002, 2008, 2009)
- SUNYAC Qualifiers ('59, '61, '62, '64, '86, '98,'99, 00, '02, '03, '04, '05, '06, '07, '08, '09)
- Kevin Broderick: 13 seasons (1996-2009), Winningest men's basketball coach in school history (209 wins), SUNYAC Coach of the Year ('98)
- Mike O'Steen: All-SUNYAC First Team ('02, '03); 2nd Team NABC All-District Team member both in 2002 and 2003
- Dave Ponza: All-SUNYAC First Team ('04), Second Team All-SUNYAC ('05)
- Nicholas Perioli: Co-First Year Player of the Year ('04), 3x All-SUNYAC (First team '05, '08; second team '06)
- Chad Burridge: SUNYAC Rookie of the Year (2009), ECAC Upstate Rookie of the Year (2009), D3Hoops.com East Region Rookie of the Year (2009)
- Tommy Downing: 2x All-SUNYAC (Second team - 2008, first team - 2009); Second team, NABC East Region All-District
- Kyle Reuter: First-team All-SUNYAC (2009)
|